Measurement

NGL Meter Station Design

Design custody transfer measurement stations for NGL products including meter selection, back pressure control, proving systems, and sampling requirements per API MPMS standards.

Purity products

Volumetric

Propane, Butane, Natural Gasoline measured by volume at net conditions.

Mixed products

Mass

Y-Grade, Ethane, E/P Mix measured by mass with composite sampling.

Proving accuracy

±0.02%

API MPMS repeatability requirement for custody transfer meters.

Use this guide when you need to:

  • Select appropriate meter technology for NGL service.
  • Design custody transfer measurement systems.
  • Determine back pressure requirements to prevent flashing.

1. Overview

NGL meter station design is not a one-size-fits-all scenario. Multiple considerations influence the station design, and all must be taken into account. The major considerations are:

  • What product or products will be measured
  • What meter technology to utilize
  • Process design limitations
Purity vs. Mixed Products: The first consideration is whether the product is a purity product or a mixed compositional product. Most purity products are measured and accounted for by volume, while mixed compositional products are measured and accounted for by mass.

Product Classification

Product Type Examples Measurement
Purity Products Propane, Butane, iso-Butane, Natural Gasoline Volumetric
Mixed Products Y-Grade, Ethane, E/P Mix, RGP, RGB Mass

2. Measurement Types

Volumetric Measurement

Volumetric measurement is used for purity products where composition is known and consistent. Volume products are sold at net conditions but measured at flowing conditions.

Net conditions are defined as equilibrium vapor pressure (EVP) at 60°F, or at 14.7 psia if the EVP of the product is less than 1 atmosphere.

To correct the product to net conditions, accurate measurement of temperature and pressure is required. These process measurements are used to calculate the CTL (Correction for Temperature of Liquid) and CPL (Correction for Pressure of Liquid) from the API MPMS product tables.

Inferred Mass Measurement

Inferred mass measurement uses a volumetric meter coupled with an online densitometer. The indicated volume is multiplied by the live flowing density to calculate the mass flow rate:

Inferred Mass: Mass = Indicated Volume × Flowing Density All three meter types (Turbine, Coriolis, PD) can be used as a primary measurement device on an inferred mass measurement skid, but the meter must be coupled with an online densitometer.

Direct Mass Measurement

Direct mass measurement uses a Coriolis meter configured to output mass directly. The Coriolis meter measures mass flow rate based on the inertial force exerted on a vibrating tube as fluid flows through it.

The meter can also measure the period frequency of the fluid to calculate density. For direct mass output, the Coriolis meter functions as both the meter and the densitometer.

3. Meter Technologies

Turbine Meters

Turbine meters are mechanical meters that convert fluid velocity into rotational velocity. Any rotational velocity component in the product stream (swirl) can affect the meter, so flow conditioning should be installed as a good design practice.

Pulse output

K-factor calibration

Pulses per unit volume, requires proving for each product.

Flow range

Linear above minimum

Under-measures below minimum flow rate.

Sensitivity

Viscosity dependent

Requires re-proving when product changes.

Positive Displacement (PD) Meters

PD meters are mechanical meters that rely on small, discrete volume pockets to measure the volumetric flow rate. They are highly repeatable and work well in flow regions and viscosities that could be problematic with other technologies.

Low flow

Excellent performance

Best choice for variable or low flow rates.

Conditioning

Not required

Flow profile disturbances have minimal effect.

Maintenance

Higher requirements

Moving parts require good filtration and lubricity.

Coriolis Meters

Coriolis meters are non-mechanical and rely on the inertial force exerted on an object as a result of movement relative to a rotating frame of reference. As flow passes through a vibrating tube, the tube begins to torque proportionally to the mass flow rate.

Measurement

Direct mass output

Also measures density from tube frequency.

Accuracy

Very linear

Can over-measure or under-measure (vs. turbine always under).

Installation

Vibration sensitive

Piping stresses can affect measurement.

Meter Technology Comparison

Characteristic Turbine PD Coriolis
Flow conditioning needed Yes No Minimal
Low flow performance Poor Excellent Fair
Dirty fluid tolerance Fair Poor Good
Direct mass output No No Yes
Maintenance Moderate High Low
Cost (large sizes) Lower Higher Moderate

4. Flow Conditioning

Meter performance can be negatively affected by flow profile distortions (swirl) created by piping effects prior to entering the meter. A general rule of thumb is that 30 pipe diameters of straight pipe is required to straighten most flow profile distortions.

Severe Disturbances: Depending on the severity of the distortion, significantly more pipe diameters may be required before the flow profile returns to normal. Some data indicates significant swirl induced by piping effects can persist for more than 200 pipe diameters.

Flow conditioners can eliminate the flow distortion in as little as 10 pipe diameters. Types of flow conditioners range from simple tube bundles to high performance flow conditioners which address both swirl and velocity profiles.

Straight Pipe Requirements

Configuration Upstream Downstream
Turbine (no conditioner) 30D minimum 5D
Turbine (with conditioner) 10D 5D
PD meters Minimal Minimal
Coriolis meters 5-10D 3-5D

D = pipe diameter

5. Back Pressure Control

A back pressure control valve should be installed on each meter run to guarantee the pressure is maintained above the minimum required to prevent vaporization.

Minimum Operating Pressure: P_min = 1.25 × EVP + 2 × Meter ΔP Where: P_min = Minimum operating pressure (psia) EVP = Equilibrium Vapor Pressure at operating temperature (psia) Meter ΔP = Pressure drop across the meter (psi) Example: EVP = 190 psia at 60°F Meter ΔP = 5 psi P_min = 1.25 × 190 + 2 × 5 = 247.5 psia
Vaporization Risk: If this parameter is not maintained, the liquid could partially vaporize causing mis-measurement. The vapor could also cause damage to the meter from high velocities in two-phase flow, or from cavitation within the meter.

6. Density Measurement

The product's temperature is required for CTL and CPL determinations. This is accomplished by two philosophies:

  1. Fixed specific gravity at 60°F - Does not require a densitometer
  2. Live flowing density - Requires a densitometer. From the flowing density along with temperature and pressure, the flow computer uses an iterative procedure to back calculate the SG at 60°F

Densitometer Types

Insertion Densitometers

Insertion densitometers have velocity limitations which are commonly exceeded by product velocities. In this case, the densitometers are installed in stilling wells off the mainline pipe. Stilling wells limit product velocities but raise concerns about maintaining a representative sample.

Flow-Through Densitometers

Flow-through densitometers (vibrating tube type or Coriolis meter density function) are installed in a sample loop. Scoops or quills should be utilized to ensure the sample is taken from the center third of the meter run piping.

Temperature Requirement: An adequate flow rate is established when the temperature at the densitometer outlet is maintained within 0.2°F of the flowing temperature of the fluid in the mainline pipe.

Facilities (pycnometer connections) must be installed to verify the density measurement. During density verification, temperatures at the densitometer outlet, mainline pipe, and pycnometer outlet must be within 0.2°F.

7. Meter Proving

For custody measurement, provisions must be installed to prove each meter run independently. The decision should be made whether the meter will be proved with a portable prover or with a permanently installed prover.

Prover Selection Factors

  • Frequency of provings
  • Number of meters to be proved
  • Location of the site
  • Operating cost vs. capital cost

Prover Operation

A prover is a device calibrated to a known volume between a set of switches. Two commonly utilized types are piston provers and ball provers. These devices calibrate the meter by accumulating the pulses generated by the meter for the known volume of the prover.

Meter Factor: MF = Prover Volume / Measured Volume The meter factor is used to correct the actual volume measured to the known volume. For mass proving (Coriolis): Inferred Prover Mass = Prover Volume × Average Density
Prover Diverter Valve: The prover diverter must be a double block and bleed valve to ensure the valve is properly seated and no flow is bypassing the prover. Bypassing flow will result in an improper meter factor.

Proving Considerations

  • Piping to the prover should be minimized to keep operating conditions close to the meter
  • Caution when volumetrically proving Ethane and Y-grade - CTL and CPL calculations can be in error for certain process conditions
  • Turbine meters require re-proving when product changes
  • Coriolis meters have phase shift between measurement and prover that can affect repeatability

8. Composite Sampling

The primary difference on a mass system is the installation of a flow-weighted composite sampler. A composite sampler is required to ensure the components within the stream are properly accounted.

Financial Impact: Errors related to composite samples and analysis can lead to component shifting issues which can have large financial impacts.

Sampler Installation

  • Located as close to the piping as possible
  • Minimize sample volume in quill, pump, and tubing
  • Use small tubing to minimize sample lag
  • Smaller, more frequent bite sizes are better than larger, less frequent

Accumulator Sizing

Accumulator pots should be adequately large enough to accommodate the sample being collected. Sampler pacing should be set such that the composite sample collected is representative of what flowed through the meter.

Dual sampler systems may be required to facilitate sample collection and analysis per contracts. Once analyzed, the analysis is applied to the totalized mass batch for component accounting.