Centrifugal Compression

Centrifugal Compressor Performance Maps

Interpret and apply compressor performance maps including speed lines, surge boundaries, stonewall limits, and fan law corrections per API 617 and OEM data.

Surge Line

Minimum Stable Flow

Operating below surge causes damage

Stonewall

Maximum Flow

Choked flow at sonic velocity

Fan Laws

Speed Scaling

Q ~ N, H ~ N^2, P ~ N^3

1. Overview

A centrifugal compressor performance map is the primary tool for predicting compressor behavior at various operating conditions. OEMs provide these maps based on factory test data, and engineers use them for system design, control philosophy, and troubleshooting.

X-Axis

Inlet Volume Flow

ICFM or ACFM at suction conditions

Y-Axis

Head or Pressure Ratio

Polytropic head (ft-lbf/lb) or P2/P1

Speed Lines

Constant RPM Curves

Typically 5-8 speeds from 70-105% Nrated

Efficiency Islands

Contour Lines

Peak efficiency at BEP; decreases off-design

Map Types

Map TypeY-AxisX-AxisBest For
Head vs. FlowPolytropic Head (ft-lbf/lb)ICFMMulti-gas applications
Pressure Ratio vs. FlowP2/P1ACFM or MMSCFDFixed-gas service
Reduced MapHead/N^2Flow/NVariable speed analysis
Power vs. FlowBHPICFMDriver sizing
Head vs. pressure ratio: Head-based maps are preferred because polytropic head is independent of gas composition (for a given Z and T). Pressure ratio maps are gas-specific and must be regenerated when gas properties change.

2. Speed Lines & Map Axes

Each speed line represents compressor behavior at a constant rotational speed. The shape reveals aerodynamic characteristics of the impeller design.

Speed Line Characteristics

RegionFlowHeadBehavior
Near SurgeLowMaximumFlat or rising curve; unstable flow imminent
BEPDesignModeratePeak efficiency; smooth operation
Right of BEPHighDecliningHead drops with increasing flow
StonewallMaximumRapidly droppingMach = 1 in passages; head collapses
Reduced Speed and Flow (API 617): N_reduced = N / sqrt(k * Z * R * T1 / MW) Q_reduced = Q / sqrt(k * Z * R * T1 / MW) Where: N = Actual speed (RPM) Q = Actual inlet volume flow (ICFM) k = Specific heat ratio Z = Compressibility factor T1 = Suction temperature (deg R) MW = Molecular weight Reduced parameters collapse multiple gas conditions onto a single curve, enabling "universal" performance prediction.

Speed Line Slope

The slope of the speed line (dH/dQ) is a critical stability indicator:

Slope SignConditionStability
Negative (dH/dQ < 0)Normal operating rangeStable: system naturally self-correcting
Zero (dH/dQ = 0)Peak head pointMarginal: onset of instability
Positive (dH/dQ > 0)Left of peakUnstable: surge region
Backward-leaning impellers produce steeper speed lines with more stable operating range. Radial impellers have flatter curves and narrower stable envelopes but achieve higher head per stage.

3. Surge Line & Stonewall

The surge line and stonewall (choke) limit define the usable operating envelope on a performance map.

Surge Line

Surge is a violent aerodynamic instability where flow periodically reverses through the compressor. The surge line connects the minimum stable flow points across all speed lines.

ParameterValueNotes
Surge frequency0.5-10 HzDeep surge < 2 Hz; mild surge 5-10 Hz
Pressure pulsation10-50% of PdCauses piping vibration and fatigue
Temperature spike50-200 deg FFlow reversal recompresses hot gas
Axial thrust reversalUp to 2x designDamages thrust bearings rapidly
Time to damageSeconds to minutesRepeated surge destroys seals and bearings

Surge Control Line (SCL)

Surge Control Line Placement: SCL = Surge Line + Safety Margin Typical margins (per API 617): Control line: 10% flow to right of surge line Trip line: 5% flow to right of surge line Q_control = Q_surge x 1.10 Q_trip = Q_surge x 1.05 The anti-surge valve opens when operating point approaches SCL, recycling gas from discharge to suction to maintain minimum flow.

Stonewall (Choke)

Stonewall occurs when gas velocity reaches sonic conditions (Mach = 1) in the impeller passages or diffuser throat. Beyond this point, increasing flow produces no additional head.

EffectConsequenceMitigation
Head collapseRapid drop to zero headLimit flow with discharge throttle
Efficiency dropFalls below 50%Avoid sustained operation in choke
Noise increaseHigh-frequency aerodynamic noiseNot structurally damaging short-term
Power increasePower may exceed driver ratingMonitor driver loading continuously
Surge vs. stonewall risk: Surge causes immediate mechanical damage and must be avoided at all times. Stonewall operation is inefficient but not immediately destructive. Anti-surge protection is always the higher priority.

4. Fan Laws & Speed Corrections

The affinity laws (fan laws) allow prediction of compressor performance at different speeds from a single test curve. These are exact for incompressible flow and approximate for compressible gas.

Affinity Laws for Centrifugal Compressors: Law 1 - Flow: Q2/Q1 = N2/N1 Law 2 - Head: H2/H1 = (N2/N1)^2 Law 3 - Power: P2/P1 = (N2/N1)^3 Where: Q = Volume flow (ICFM) H = Polytropic head (ft-lbf/lb) P = Power (HP) N = Rotational speed (RPM) Compressibility Correction: For gases (k != 1.0), fan laws are approximate. Accuracy degrades at: Pressure ratios > 2.5 Mach numbers > 0.8 Speed changes > +/- 15% from test speed For better accuracy, use Schultz correction factors or OEM software.

Speed Change Effects

Speed ChangeFlow ChangeHead ChangePower Change
-20% (80% N)-20%-36%-49%
-10% (90% N)-10%-19%-27%
Design (100% N)100%100%100%
+5% (105% N)+5%+10%+16%
+10% (110% N)+10%+21%+33%

Variable Speed vs. Throttling

Control MethodTurndownEfficiency ImpactCapital Cost
Variable speed (VSD)50-105%Follows cubic law; minimal penaltyHigh (VFD cost)
Suction throttle70-100%Moderate loss; reduces densityLow (valve only)
Inlet guide vanes65-100%Pre-swirl changes impeller workModerate
Discharge throttle70-100%High loss; wastes energy as heatLow (valve only)
Anti-surge recycle0-100%Very poor; recompresses recycled gasRequired for safety
Variable speed is preferred for applications with significant flow variation. Power savings follow the cube law: reducing speed by 10% saves 27% power. Over a 20-year life, VSD payback is typically 2-4 years in pipeline service.

5. Operating Envelope

The operating envelope defines all allowable combinations of flow and head. It is bounded by the surge line, stonewall, minimum speed, maximum continuous speed (MCS), and driver power limit.

Envelope Boundaries

BoundaryLimiting FactorConsequence of Violation
Surge line (left)Aerodynamic instabilityFlow reversal, mechanical damage
Stonewall (right)Sonic velocity in passagesHead collapse, power overload
MCS (top)Rotor stress, bearing DN limitRotor burst, bearing failure
Minimum speed (bottom)Oil lift-off, resonance avoidanceBearing damage, vibration
Power limitDriver rated powerMotor trip, turbine overtemp

Operating Point Determination

System Resistance Curve: H_system = H_static + K * Q^2 Where: H_static = Static head (pressure difference at zero flow) K = System resistance coefficient (friction, valves, etc.) Q = Volume flow The operating point is the intersection of the speed line and system resistance curve. Multiple Operating Cases: Summer/Winter (temperature changes gas density) Beginning/End of field life (flow rate changes) Clean/Fouled (resistance changes) Design must ensure all cases fall within the operating envelope.
API 617 requires the compressor manufacturer to demonstrate adequate surge margin at all specified operating points, including off-design conditions such as turndown, gas composition changes, and fouled conditions.

6. Gas Property Corrections

Performance maps are generated for a specific gas composition and suction conditions. When actual conditions differ, corrections are required.

Correction Factors

Volume Flow Correction: Q_corrected = Q_actual * (Z_test * T_test * P_actual) / (Z_actual * T_actual * P_test) Head Correction (Approximate): H_corrected = H_test * (MW_test / MW_actual) * (Z_actual / Z_test) * (T_actual / T_test) Power Correction: BHP_corrected = BHP_test * (MW_actual / MW_test) * (P_actual / P_test) * (T_test / T_actual) * (Z_test / Z_actual)
Property ChangeEffect on FlowEffect on HeadEffect on Power
MW increases 10%No change (ICFM)Decreases ~10%Increases ~10%
T1 increases 20 deg FIncreases ~2%Increases ~2%Approximately constant
P1 increases 10%Decreases ~10%No changeIncreases ~10%
k increases 5%NegligibleNegligibleIncreases ~3%
Z decreases 5%Increases ~5%Decreases ~5%Approximately constant
When to re-rate: If gas MW changes by more than 5%, Z changes by more than 3%, or suction temperature changes by more than 30 deg F, request an updated performance map from the OEM rather than relying on correction factors.

7. Worked Examples

Example 1: Reading a Performance Map

Given: Compressor map at 100% speed (N = 11,000 RPM) Design point: Q = 5,000 ICFM, Hp = 42,000 ft-lbf/lb Surge point at 100%: Q_surge = 3,200 ICFM Stonewall at 100%: Q_choke = 7,500 ICFM Find: Surge margin and stable range Step 1: Surge margin SM = (Q_design - Q_surge) / Q_design x 100% SM = (5,000 - 3,200) / 5,000 x 100% = 36% (> 10% minimum per API 617) Step 2: Stable operating range Range = (Q_choke - Q_surge) / Q_design x 100% Range = (7,500 - 3,200) / 5,000 x 100% = 86% Step 3: Turndown ratio Turndown = Q_surge / Q_design = 3,200 / 5,000 = 64% Maximum turndown at 100% speed = 36%

Example 2: Fan Law Speed Correction

Given: At N1 = 11,000 RPM: Q1 = 5,000 ICFM, H1 = 42,000 ft-lbf/lb, BHP1 = 3,500 HP Find: Performance at N2 = 9,900 RPM (90% speed) Step 1: Speed ratio N2/N1 = 9,900 / 11,000 = 0.900 Step 2: New flow Q2 = Q1 x (N2/N1) = 5,000 x 0.900 = 4,500 ICFM Step 3: New head H2 = H1 x (N2/N1)^2 = 42,000 x 0.810 = 34,020 ft-lbf/lb Step 4: New power BHP2 = BHP1 x (N2/N1)^3 = 3,500 x 0.729 = 2,552 HP Power savings: 948 HP (27%) for 10% speed reduction

Example 3: Gas Composition Change

Given: Test gas: MW = 18.5, k = 1.28, Z = 0.92 Actual gas: MW = 21.2, k = 1.22, Z = 0.88 Test performance: Hp = 42,000 ft-lbf/lb, BHP = 3,500 HP Find: Corrected performance for actual gas Step 1: Corrected head (polytropic head changes with MW) H_corrected = 42,000 x (18.5/21.2) x (0.88/0.92) H_corrected = 42,000 x 0.8726 x 0.9565 = 35,058 ft-lbf/lb Step 2: Corrected power BHP_corrected = 3,500 x (21.2/18.5) x (0.92/0.88) BHP_corrected = 3,500 x 1.146 x 1.045 = 4,192 HP Result: Heavier gas produces less head but requires more power. Verify driver has adequate margin for the heavier gas case.